On Daruma's Watch
monthly small-cap insights for investment professionalsSeptember 2010
Vol. 3 No. 9
Frequent and direct client communication is a critical (and often overlooked) element in the success of a money management firm. Today's newsletter explains why, and offers five specific suggestions for staying on track.
All the best,
Mariko O. Gordon, CFA
Founder, CEO and CIO
Daruma Asset Management, Inc.
Say What You Need To SayIn our family, Labor Day weekends are usually squandered on soccer tournaments. But not this year. This year, we labored instead at letting go, as we installed our eldest son ("Thing One") into his new school - Middlesex - in Concord, Massachusetts, just a stone's throw from Walden Pond.
Ostensibly Haden switched schools as a junior in order to play more competitive soccer. In reality, it had as much to do with his being heartily sick of us; few things in life are as mortifying as one's family, especially when you're seventeen.
As the big day drew near - and blessed with a previously well-hidden gift for organization (who knew?) - Haden wrote out detailed lists and packed things with the crisp precision of an English butler. All we had to do on moving day was start driving at dawn, deliver unsolicited advice for three and a half hours (revenge for having to stifle blubbering for several days), and undergo a separation process carefully orchestrated by the school.
Along with the other new boarding school parents, we sat in a circle in dorm master Dan Scheibe's living room, soaking up his tactful advice on how not to be a helicopter parent. Among his useful insights were specific guidelines regarding the frequency, medium and timing of communications.
Apparently, calling five or six times a week is viewed as excessive, as is persistent nagging via e-mail and/or texting. And while we were invited to stay in touch, we were also given a long list of times that weren't good to call, including during study hall hours, after lights out, early in the morning, etc. (Frankly, it might have been simpler to just specify the hour and a half window between sports and dinner when communication is applauded.)
But we got the picture. In fact, all of this effort on drawing appropriate boundaries around communication made me think about how we as money managers can best communicate with our clients about the assets they leave in our care.
As an industry, we can be very cavalier about the way we stay in touch (when the SEC starts agitating for financial disclosure documents to be written in the vernacular, you know it's bad). We tend to forget that our clients, while viewing us as in loco parentis, haven't given up on their "kids" (assets); they want and expect to receive meaningful progress reports.
When we started Daruma in 1995, those who invested with us were counting as much on our communications skills as on our investing prowess. The old adage "no one gets fired for hiring IBM" also holds true in our business and we knew our clients were putting their reputations as well as their money on the line by placing their confidence in our newly hatched firm.
We honor that confidence by being transparent, sometimes to the point of TMI (too much information). Specifically, here's what we've learned, based on what clients have told us they like about our reports:
But why focus on the same one or two economic statistics that happen to be in fashion at the moment? (Remember when everyone was tracking M2 in the early 80s?) If you don't have a different point of view to share, don't waste your clients' time with echolalia.
Clients are much more likely to be interested in the fix to a problem when they don't feel lied to.
One large and well-respected firm blew up recently because their quantitative model was broken and they took a long time to figure it out, fix it, and own up to it. Who knows what really went down, but I can tell you that a sacred trust was broken, because we got a flurry of calls asking if we'd like to pitch for their business.
When there's bad news to share, get out in front of it.
Trying to sound smart by using lots of multisyllabic words (see?), abstract nouns that confuse rather than clarify, and heaps o' jargon, does nothing to improve communication. I don't know about you, but I want to talk to my kids' teachers and advisors without using the latest in pedagogical terminology.
If they're clear and direct, I'm going to believe that they know what they're talking about. If they throw a bunch of words at me like so much tear gas, I'm not going to trust them.
So ask yourself ... What information do your clients need? What must they really know to understand what's happening to their money?
We can all parse data six ways from Sunday. But if a chart doesn't shed light - or worse, distracts from what's really happening - it doesn't belong in your report.
Here's the point. If you sound like everyone else, if your words and graphics are confusing, if your thought processes appear to be a mess, if your language is obfuscatory ... you will be perceived as incapable at best and a liar at worst. Either way, you'll have given me no reason to stick with you when performance hits a rough patch.
As money managers we take in assets with the hope that the capital we've been entrusted with will grow, by dint of our efforts. Staying in touch with frequent and direct communication helps us manage the inevitable separation anxiety, be developmentally appropriate, and create healthy boundaries, so that both parties can get on with their lives.
Daruma Vs. The Beaten PathWhile fooling around with the "highly accurate" statistical measuring tool, Wordle, we discovered that Daruma's Q2 2010 performance commentary looked different than those of other managers.
When comparing ours to a composite of three different firms we noticed that Daruma used more stock-specific names and a broader range of words. (Plus our Wordle is oval-shaped and theirs looks like a footprint, but we're pretty sure that's an irrelevant distinction.)
How about you? Are you giving your communications your own, fresh spin?
Shameless Self PromotionOops... we did it again! Daruma has been selected once more by PSN as one of the "Top Ten Small-Cap Core Managers," this time in its Top Guns Special Edition.
PSN, the well-known online investment manager database, tracks manager performance and other portfolio characteristics. Click to read the report.
About UsFounded in 1995, Daruma Asset Management invests in a high-conviction portfolio of no more than 35 small-cap stocks.
Daruma manages $1 billion for public and corporate pension plans, endowments, foundations and individuals. Our annualized return since inception is 11.7% vs. 6.3%, net of fees (7/28/95 through 06/30/10).
(Notes to Performance: http://www.darumanyc.com/disclosures.htm)
For more information about the work we do, please visit us at www.darumanyc.com.
© 2010 Daruma Asset Management, Inc.